Pre-Owned
1951 Bowman Mickey Mantle #253 PSA 2.5
Product ID: SC13535
Looking to Sell Something Similar? Get an Appraisal
Have questions? We’re here to help.
Call us at 800-636-6000 | Email: info@rittenhouseestatebuyers.com
Own a piece of baseball history with this iconic 1951 Bowman Mickey Mantle #253, professionally graded PSA 2.5. This legendary rookie card captures "The Mick" at the dawn of his Hall of Fame career, making it one of the most coveted collectibles in the sports card world. The 1951 Bowman design showcases Mantle's youthful determination with its classic hand-colored photography and clean aesthetic that defined the golden age of baseball cards. Despite its Good+ grade, this card retains strong visual appeal with clear imagery and intact borders, representing exceptional value for collectors seeking an authentic piece of Mantle memorabilia. As Mickey Mantle's true rookie card, the 1951 Bowman #253 holds immense significance in baseball card collecting. Mantle's incredible 18-season career with the New York Yankees produced 536 home runs, seven World Series championships, and three MVP awards, cementing his status as one of baseball's greatest legends. This particular card is part of a complete 1951 Bowman set, offering serious collectors a rare opportunity to acquire multiple vintage treasures. The PSA authentication guarantees the card's authenticity and condition, providing confidence in your investment. Perfect for dedicated collectors, investors, or Yankees enthusiasts looking to own a tangible connection to baseball's most celebrated era.
1951 Bowman Mickey Mantle #253 PSA 2.5
Product images gallery
Pre-Owned
More Details
Brand
Other
Year
Pre- 1970's
Product Category
Baseball
Graded Service / Grade
PSA — 2.5
Card Details
1951 Bowman Mickey Mantle
Other
— Pre- 1970's
— #253
— Mickey Mantle
Autographed
No
Certification
#72979185
Authenticity Guarantee
At Rittenhouse Estate Buyers, every item we sell is 100% authentic — guaranteed.
Each piece is carefully inspected, tested, and verified by our team of experts to ensure its authenticity and quality. From luxury watches and fine jewelry to designer handbags and collectibles, we stand behind every item we offer.
Shop with confidence knowing that your purchase is genuine, accurately represented, and backed by our commitment to integrity and transparency.
What is Pre-Loved?
“Pre-loved” simply means previously owned — luxury pieces that have been cared for and cherished, now ready to be enjoyed again. Choosing pre-loved allows you to own authentic designer items at exceptional value, often in like-new condition, while also promoting sustainability by giving timeless pieces a second life.
Why Choose Rittenhouse Estate Buyers
At Rittenhouse Estate Buyers, we combine decades of expertise with a modern, trustworthy approach to luxury buying and selling. Whether you’re looking to sell your valuables or shop for something exceptional, our mission is simple — to deliver fair value, professionalism, and peace of mind every step of the way.
We offer immediate, competitive offers on fine jewelry, watches, gold, designer handbags, and collectibles — all evaluated by experienced professionals, not algorithms. Our storefront in the heart of Rittenhouse Square provides a secure, discreet, and comfortable environment, while our online process offers the same level of care and transparency from the convenience of your home.
When you shop with us, you’ll find a curated selection of authenticated pre-loved luxury pieces, each verified for quality and authenticity, priced well below retail.
Choose Rittenhouse Estate Buyers for the expertise, honesty, and personalized experience that larger chains and online marketplaces simply can’t match.
Frequently Asked Questions
Shipping and Delivery
All orders are processed within 1–3 business days after payment has been received and verified. Orders are not shipped or delivered on weekends or holidays.
If we experience a high volume of orders, shipments may be delayed by a few days. We will notify you via email if there is a significant delay.
Shipping Rates & Delivery Estimates
Shipping charges for your order will be calculated and displayed at checkout.
We primarily ship through UPS, FedEx, or USPS, depending on the value and destination of the item.
Standard Shipping: 3–7 business days
Expedited Shipping: 1–3 business days
Overnight Shipping: 1 business day (available upon request)
Delivery delays can occasionally occur due to carrier issues or weather conditions.
Shipment Confirmation & Tracking
You will receive a shipment confirmation email once your order has shipped, containing your tracking number(s). The tracking number will be active within 24 hours.
Insurance
All shipments are fully insured for the value of the item while in transit. Once the package is marked as delivered by the carrier, responsibility for the item transfers to the recipient.
Signature Requirement
For security purposes, a signature is required upon delivery for all orders over $500 in value. If you prefer to waive this requirement, please contact us before your item ships (note that doing so releases us from liability once the carrier marks the package delivered).
Shipping to P.O. Boxes
We do not ship high-value items to P.O. boxes. Please provide a physical address for delivery.
International Shipping
We currently ship within the United States only. For international requests, please contact us directly to discuss available options and shipping rates.
Damages or Lost Packages
We take every precaution to ensure your item arrives safely. However, if your order arrives damaged or does not arrive within the expected timeframe:
Please contact us immediately at [your email] or [your phone number].
Save all packaging materials and damaged goods before filing a claim.
We will assist you in filing a claim with the carrier and resolving the issue promptly.
Contact Information
If you have any questions about your shipment, please contact us at:
📧 info@rittenhouseestatebuyers.com
📞 800-636-6000
Payment
We accept cash, bank wire, and all major credit/debit cards (Visa, MasterCard, Amex, Discover).
A 3% processing fee applies to all credit and debit card payments.
To avoid fees, customers are welcome to pay via cash or bank wire transfer.
Full payment is due at the time of purchase, and items are released or shipped once funds clear.
All sales are final, and high-value transactions may require ID verification.
How Does the Selling Process Work?
You can sell to us in-store or online — whichever is more convenient for you.
If you visit our showroom, you’re welcome to walk in or make an appointment for a private evaluation. Our team will inspect, authenticate, and evaluate your items before making a cash offer based on current market value and salability.
Prefer to sell online? Our sister company, SellMyJewelry.com, makes it simple. You’ll receive a free, insured mail-in kit to send your items. Once received, we go through the same inspection and evaluation process and make a cash offer. If you choose not to sell, your items are returned at no cost to you.
Visit Us
Book an Appointment to View an Item In-Person
Located in the heart of Philadelphia on 250 South 18th St, just steps from Rittenhouse Square.
Walk-ins are always welcome, or book a private appointment for a one-on-one experience with our experts.